Icelandic Pickled Herring: A Marinated Herring Recipe for Christmas Síld

Sigrún Ólafsdóttir

Sigrún Ólafsdóttir

· 8 min read
Pieces of marinated herring fillet with silvery skin lined up on a pale blue oval platter with rings of sliced onion

In December, Icelandic supermarket fridges fill up with jars of herring. There is herring in sweet spiced brine, herring in curry sauce, herring with mustard, dill or beetroot, and festive Christmas versions with berries and warm spices.

For many families, a plate of síld on dark rye bread is as much a part of the season as smoked lamb and leaf bread. It turns up at Christmas buffets, at family lunches between the holidays and on the New Year table.

Shop-bought jars are good, but marinated herring is surprisingly easy to make at home. Here is where the tradition comes from, a reliable marinated herring recipe and the curry sauce Icelanders love to stir it into.

Why herring matters so much in Iceland

Herring shaped modern Iceland more than almost any other fish. In 1903 Norwegian fishermen arrived in Siglufjörður in the north, built salting stations and set off what Icelanders still call the herring adventure.

Over the next decades the small village grew into a town of more than three thousand people, with salting stations and factories along the harbour. In some years herring from Siglufjörður alone made up over a fifth of Iceland's exports.

The boom ended abruptly. Heavy fishing and colder seas in the 1960s pushed the Norwegian-Icelandic herring stock towards collapse, and in 1969 the herring failed to appear off the north coast. The story is told today at the award-winning Herring Era Museum in Siglufjörður.

Why síld belongs to Christmas

No one has written down exactly why herring became Christmas food, but the timing makes sense. Herring was traditionally salted at sea or right after landing, and by December the barrels were ready to eat.

Herring on buttered rye bread is also a close cousin of the Danish open sandwich, and centuries of Danish rule left Iceland with a taste for cold Christmas buffets where several kinds of herring sit side by side.

Today it sits alongside smoked lamb, laufabrauð and sweet desserts in our guide to Icelandic Christmas food. It is usually eaten as a starter or as part of a cold spread, a few pieces at a time.

Choosing your herring

Almost all homemade pickled herring in Scandinavia starts with salted herring rather than fresh fish. Salt-cured fillets have already been preserved, firmed up and seasoned, so all you need to do is soak and marinate them.

Look for salted herring fillets in Nordic, Dutch, German or Eastern European shops, sold in tubs or vacuum packs. Whole salted herring works too, but you will need to fillet and skin them yourself.

If you only have fresh herring, it must be frozen before it is eaten without cooking, because raw herring can carry parasites. EU rules call for at least 24 hours at -20°C or colder, and the fish then needs a salt cure before it goes into the sweet brine.

Marinated herring recipe (marineruð síld)

This is the classic sweet-sour pickled herring found across the Nordic countries, built on the old 1-2-3 brine: one part strong vinegar, two parts sugar and three parts water. It makes enough for six to eight people as part of a buffet.

Ingredients

  • 500 g salted herring fillets
  • 300 ml water
  • 100 ml 12% spirit vinegar (or 240 ml ordinary 5% white vinegar plus 160 ml water)
  • 170 g sugar (about 200 ml)
  • 1 red onion, thinly sliced
  • 1 small carrot, thinly sliced (optional)
  • 10 allspice berries and 10 black peppercorns, lightly crushed
  • 2 bay leaves
  • 1 tsp yellow mustard seeds
  • A few sprigs of fresh dill

Method

  1. Soak the fillets in plenty of cold water in the fridge for 12 to 24 hours, changing the water two or three times. Taste a small piece: it should be pleasantly salty, not harsh.
  2. Put the water, vinegar, sugar, allspice, peppercorns, bay leaves and mustard seeds in a pan. Warm gently until the sugar dissolves, then take it off the heat and let it cool completely.
  3. Drain the herring, pat it dry and cut it into pieces about 2 to 3 cm wide.
  4. Layer the herring with the onion, carrot and dill in a clean glass jar, then pour over the cold brine so the fish is fully covered.
  5. Close the jar and refrigerate for at least 24 hours, ideally two to three days, before serving.

Kept cold and covered with brine, homemade pickled herring stays good for about a week. Always lift pieces out with a clean fork.

Curry herring (karrýsíld)

Curry herring is one of the most popular kinds of síld in Iceland, and it shows how happily Icelanders mix old Nordic food with a little spice. Mild curry and sour cream soften the sharp brine and turn the herring golden yellow.

Ingredients

  • 250 g marinated herring, drained and patted dry
  • 100 g mayonnaise
  • 100 g sour cream (Icelanders use 36% sýrður rjómi)
  • 1½ tsp mild curry powder
  • ½ tsp ground turmeric
  • 1 tsp Dijon mustard and 1 tsp wholegrain mustard
  • A squeeze of lemon juice
  • Salt and pepper
  • ½ small apple, finely diced (optional)

Method

Stir the mayonnaise, sour cream, mustards, curry powder, turmeric and lemon juice together, and season with salt and pepper. Fold in the herring and apple gently so the pieces keep their shape.

Chill for a few hours before serving so the flavours come together. Drain the herring well first, or the brine will thin the sauce.

More ways Icelanders flavour síld

Once you have a jar of plain marinated herring, it is easy to make two or three versions for the table. Mustard herring folds the fish into a sweet mustard and dill sauce, much like the Swedish senapssill.

Beetroot herring gets its pink colour from a day in brine mixed with beetroot juice, often with grated horseradish for heat. Festive jólasíld from Icelandic producers is typically spiced with flavours such as cinnamon, cloves, juniper and blackcurrant.

A simple sour cream sauce is another easy option. Mix sour cream with chopped red onion, chives or dill and a little sugar, then fold in drained pickled herring.

How to serve it

The classic way is on thin slices of dark rye bread spread generously with butter. Our Icelandic rye bread recipe gives you the dense, sweet loaf that suits herring perfectly.

Slices of boiled egg, warm new potatoes, raw red onion and fresh dill all work well on the side. Serve two or three kinds of herring together and let people build their own open sandwiches.

Herring is a mild starting point compared with the stronger fish Icelanders eat in winter. If you want to explore further, read about Icelandic fermented fish, from hákarl to the skate served before Christmas.

Tips for the best result

Give the herring time. After one day the brine has done its work, but after two or three the flavour is rounder and the onion has mellowed.

Taste as you go. Salted herring varies a lot by brand, so adjust the soaking time rather than following the clock blindly.

Make it ahead. Marinated herring is ideal party food because it is finished days before guests arrive, leaving the oven free for the roast.

A small jar with a big history

A jar of síld connects a modern Christmas table with the busy salting stations of Siglufjörður and the herring girls who worked them. It costs little, takes a few minutes of real work and keeps the old flavours alive.

Make a jar this December, add a bowl of curry herring beside it and set out plenty of buttered rye bread. It is one of the easiest ways to bring an Icelandic Christmas into your own kitchen.

Cover photo: "Aringa marinato" by Kagor, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Sigrún Ólafsdóttir

About Sigrún Ólafsdóttir

Sigrún grew up baking rúgbrauð with her grandmother in Akureyri and has spent the last decade collecting recipes from kitchens all over Iceland. She writes Icelandic MAT's recipes, one dish at a time.

Copyright © 2026 Icelandic MAT. All rights reserved.
Traditional Icelandic recipes for home cooks.